Methodology
How Tallyard calculators work
Every calculator on this site follows the same three principles: the formula is public, the sources are cited, and the answer is shown with its supporting math. This page explains how we put those principles into practice.
Formulas
Each calculator's formula is displayed directly on the page, in the “Show the math” section below the result. You see every input, every intermediate step, and the final result. If we apply a waste factor, a rounding rule, or a coverage rate, it appears explicitly in the calculation steps.
For example, the paint calculator uses: gallons = (perimeter × height − doors × 20 − windows × 15) × coats ÷ coverage, where coverage defaults to 350 sq ft/gal (one coat, smooth surface). The formula, the default, and the source of the coverage rate are all visible.
Sources
Coverage rates, sizing factors, and code requirements are sourced from four categories, listed in order of preference:
- Manufacturer product data. Coverage per gallon (paint), yield per bag (concrete), capacity per unit (air conditioning tonnage). These come directly from product data sheets published by manufacturers like Benjamin Moore, Quikrete, Trane, and James Hardie.
- Building codes. Stair rise and run limits (IRC R311.7), egress window minimums (IRC R310), drain pipe sizing (IPC Table 710.1), insulation R-values by climate zone (IECC Table R402.1.2). We cite the specific code section for every code-derived value.
- Industry standards. ACCA Manual J for HVAC load calculations, APA for engineered wood, NADRA for deck construction, NKBA for kitchen layout. These fill gaps between manufacturer data and building codes.
- Aggregated cost data. For cost estimates in guides, we use HomeGuide, Angi, NerdWallet cost reports, and EIA energy pricing. We note the source date and identify that cost data is approximate and regionally variable.
Every calculator page links to its specific sources at the bottom. If a source goes stale (manufacturer updates a product line, code gets revised), we update the calculator and note it in the methodology section.
Rounding
Calculator results are rounded up to practical purchase units. You can't buy 2.67 gallons of paint, and ordering 5.4 cubic yards of concrete is a recipe for a short pour. So we round the result to the nearest buyable quantity and show both the raw and rounded numbers.
Waste factors are applied before rounding. A 10% waste factor on 4.8 cubic yards of concrete becomes 5.28, rounded to 5.5. The waste factor is always displayed in the formula steps so you can remove it if you're confident in your measurements.
What calculators are not
Tallyard calculators produce material estimates for planning. They are not engineering specifications, structural calculations, permit applications, or professional assessments. Several important things they do not account for:
- Site-specific conditions (soil type, grading, drainage, existing structural problems)
- Local code amendments that differ from the model codes we reference
- Material availability and pricing in your specific market
- Labor costs, permit fees, and inspection requirements
- Structural load calculations (always get an engineer for load-bearing work)
For structural, electrical, plumbing, or anything where safety is involved, hire a licensed professional. The calculator gives you a starting estimate for budgeting and material ordering; the professional gives you the final answer.
How guides are researched
Buying guides follow a separate process. Each guide is researched by the founder (Ash K.) against current industry data, with total-cost-of-ownership calculations showing their assumptions explicitly. Guide methodology notes (expandable at the top of each article) disclose energy price sources, cost data vintage, and modeling limitations. Sources are linked at the bottom.
Guides do not accept sponsored content, paid placements, or affiliate commissions. Manufacturer names appear only when relevant to the recommendation (naming a specific cold-climate heat pump model, for example). No manufacturer pays for inclusion.
Corrections
Found an error? Email hello@tallyard.com with the calculator name, what you expected, and what you got. We investigate and correct confirmed errors within 48 hours, noting the correction in the calculator's methodology section.
Primary source directory
Every calculator formula traces back to one or more of these sources. We reference specific sections, tables, and product data sheets — not summaries or secondary sources.
Building codes: International Residential Code (IRC) 2021 — sections R301 (design criteria), R311 (means of egress/stairs), R402 (insulation), R507 (decks), R602 (wall framing), R806 (ventilation), R1003 (chimneys). International Plumbing Code (IPC) — Table 710.1 (drain fixture units). National Electrical Code (NEC) 2023 — Table 310.16 (ampacity), Article 210 (branch circuits).
Industry standards: ACCA Manual J (HVAC load calculations), ASTM C270 (mortar), ASTM C62/C216 (brick), ANSI A108 (tile installation), ASCE 7-22 Chapter 7 (snow loads), TCNA Handbook (tile and grout), AWC DCA6 (prescriptive deck construction).
Industry associations: NADRA (decks and railing), NWFA (wood flooring), APA (engineered wood), BIA (brick), PCA (cement and concrete), NRMCA (ready-mix concrete), ARMA (asphalt roofing), ICPI (interlocking concrete pavement), CSIA (chimney safety), AFA (fencing), PHTA (pool and hot tub).
Manufacturer specifications: Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams, Behr (paint coverage). GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed (roofing). Trex, TimberTech (composite decking). James Hardie, LP SmartSide (siding). Mapei, Laticrete (grout). Owens Corning, Rockwool (insulation).
Government and research: US Department of Energy (insulation fact sheets). Energy Information Administration (residential energy rates). IRS Section 25D/25C (solar and heat pump tax credits). NREL PVWatts (solar resource data). NOAA (precipitation data for rainwater calculators).
Cost data: HomeGuide, Angi, and Fixr contractor cost databases. RS Means residential cost data. EnergySage solar marketplace reports. Remodeling Magazine Cost vs Value report.
Quality process
Each calculator goes through four steps before publishing. First, formula research: we identify the primary source (code section, manufacturer spec, or industry standard) and verify it against at least one secondary source. Second, implementation: the formula is coded with unit conversion, rounding to practical purchase units, and waste factor application. Third, verification: we test the calculator against known examples (a 10×12 slab should output 1.5 cubic yards at 4 inches; a 200 LF fence at 8-foot spacing should output 26 posts). Fourth, documentation: the formula, sources, and methodology note are written and displayed on the calculator page so any user can verify the math independently.
Pricing data is updated when we publish new cost guides or when source databases (HomeGuide, Angi, RS Means) release annual updates. Material formulas (area, volume, unit counts) do not change unless the underlying code or standard is revised. Formulas are universal. Cost estimates and building code references are US-specific.